I’ve been spending some time with a Google Home at my office. It’s. been a pretty interesting experience overall and makes me more confident in my previous assertion that of the big three in tech (Apple, Google, and Microsoft), Google is going to dominate the digital assistant / bot space. While my experience with Home was not perfect, it was a pretty impressive showing for a first generation device.
The Good: Google Home is smart as a whip! There’s just no way around that. My office mate and I spent hours trying to trip it up on trivia, calculations, and finding obscure movie and song facts and the device held up just fine. By far the most useful functionality for our office has been dictating songs to it and passing back and forth; prior to the Home, we would take turns playing (put your hate in the comments) vinyl records. Sure, we could do this with a PC or even an iPad but just being able to pick songs verbally has been an surprisingly enjoyable experience. I know this sounds a bit silly, but it reminds me of when I got my first iPad – I had mocked the iPad as just a large iPod Touch, but I changed my tune after my first few minutes using Apple’s tablet. This is just how I feel about Home, though I went in with a little more of an open mind than I did with the iPad.
The microphone seems fine but I do occasionally have to re-state requests to the device and it’s not clear if I just mumbled or my NJ accent was too hard for Home to parse on certain phrases. The speakers are pretty good and don’t have that tinny quality to the sounds that I was worried about before I got the device. For most users Home will likely be the highest quality speaker they have in their house, but I can see audiophiles wanting something a bit more.
The Bad: I’ve experienced occasional service outages with Home that required it to the restarted. The error message given suggests that my wifi may have been to blame, but every other device on the network was fine. It’s impossible to dig deeper into this, but it stands to reason that the issue is a service hiccup on Google’s end. Silly as it sounds, it kills the magic of a voice interface if you have to get up (in my experience) every other day to unplug and restart the device.
The Ugly: Google account management is a mess on just about every Google product and Home is not exception. Home only allows you to have one account on the device — this is a terrible design decision as it makes the assumption that one account equals one person. The reality for my use case and many others is that on e person will have multiple accounts. My guess is the most common case would be users (like me) have one Google account personally that has their Play Music, YouTube Red, and other Google entertainment services on it and also have a Google Work account used primarily for email and (most importantly for the purposes of Home) calendar. In my case, I put my personal Gmail on Home to get the entertainment functionality but am totally cut off from my work calendar. Ideally, I’d like a system where Google understands that users have different Google accounts for different contexts and allows the user to take calendar services from a Google Work account while using their personal account for entertainment and everything else.